Write the problem hypothesis
For [specific user], completing [job] is difficult because [missing capability], causing [measurable consequence].
You can name one user, one situation and one measurable consequence without proposing a feature.[Bug] Grounding rejects valid multi-metric claims because one metric kind is applied to the whole clause
Evidence observed in HKUDS/Vibe-Trading, a Finance project.
2 comments0 positive reactions1 days openProject Radar 93
bug
Start free validation sprint4 guided steps · private notes · cloud sync
SOURCE EVIDENCE
Read original GitHub Issue ↗Start with what users actually said
Reporter context: Description The grounding validator can reject a final-answer clause containing multiple valid analysis metrics, even when each metric is individually backed by matching evidence. This reproduces on an unmodified Vibe-Trading v0.1.15 checkout. The issue appears to be that resolves a single metric kind for the whole…Excerpted from the public Issue. Read the complete thread before interpreting it.
Recruit: Recruit people who perform the workflow with real controls, reconciliations or reporting deadlines.
Guardrail: Use anonymized or synthetic records and require human review for financial decisions and regulated outputs.
Interview five finance operators, analysts or accountants
- When did you last need this?
- What outcome were you trying to reach?
- What did you use instead?
- How often does this occur?
- What commitment would prove it matters?
Run the smallest experiment
Deliver the outcome manually or with a narrow prototype before building a reusable feature.
A user completes the real workflow and commits time, data, distribution or budget to repeat it.Use anonymized or synthetic records and require human review for financial decisions and regulated outputs.Make a build decision
- Build: repeated pain and active commitment
- Narrow: pain is real but the audience or job differs
- Stop: weak frequency or no behavioral proof
Why this brief exists
Information has value only when it changes action. This page turns one public signal into a bounded validation exercise. It is a research aid, not proof of demand, investment advice or a product recommendation.